Establishing a National DNA Database in India

June 4, 2022, 2:40 p.m.   prateekmudgal1234  
Pens of Law students    


Author: Sadhana Swaminathan, is a 3rd law student currently pursuing her law from RGNUL, Punjab

INTRODUCTION

One of the most groundbreaking discoveries in the field of genetics was an accidental one. In 1984, British geneticist Sir Alec Jeffery found his ‘eureka’ moment when he saw the X-ray film image of DNA that was left in a photographic developing tank overnight. The film showed a sequence of bars, indicating both similarities and differences between the DNA of the members of the same family. This meant that an individual can be identified by their distinct DNA. Jeffery, who wanted to study how diseases were inherited, ended up discovering a method that would revolutionize the criminal justice system. This method is called DNA fingerprinting and later came to be known as DNA profiling. DNA profiling is the process of analyzing a DNA sample to find out if that source of the bodily sample is identical to another. This method is used in locating criminals, establishing paternity and identifying unknown deceased and missing persons. It was initially used in immigration and paternity suits. DNA profiling was applied in forensic science for the first time in the Colin Pitchfork case. In 1983, the body of 15-year-old Lynda Mann was found in Leicestershire, UK. She was raped and strangled to death. The case remained unsolved as there were no suspects.

In 1986, in the same town, the body of another 15-year-old girl called Dawn Ashworth was discovered. She was also brutally raped and strangled to death. The police connected Ashworth’s murder to that of Mann’s. They arrested Richard Buckland, a 17-year-old boy with intellectual disabilities. Buckland confessed to killing Ashworth but denied the rape and murder of Mann. The police were perplexed as the modus operandi of both the murders was similar. They contacted Alec Jeffery who used his DNA fingerprinting method to compare the semen samples found in both the murders against a blood sample from Buckland. Jeffery concluded that the crimes were committed by the same person but that wasn’t Richard Buckland. Buckland was the first individual to have been found innocent by DNA profiling. Later, the killer Colin Pitchfork was arrested with the help of DNA evidence. This shows that DNA profiling not only puts criminals behind bars but also ensures the exoneration of innocents[i].

THE NATIONAL DNA DATABASE (NDNAD) IN THE UK

The United Kingdom was the first country to use DNA evidence in court and soon emerged as a world leader in using DNA in forensic science. It also established the National DNA Database in 1995, the first of its kind in the world. It is also one of the largest DNA databases containing 4.8 million profiles, which is nearly 8 per cent of the UK’s population and it grows every year[ii]. The effectiveness of the NDNAD can be measured according to several criteria; one of them is the match rate. Match rate refers to the rate at which a DNA sample collected from a crime scene matches the DNA of an individual already stored in the database. The match rate capacity of the database was highest in 2017~2018 at 66%.

DNA databases also serve as an effective tool to deter crimes. In a survey undertaken by economist Jennifer Doleac, it was observed that offenders of serious crimes whose DNA samples were in the system are 17% less likely to re-offend than those who haven’t given their samples[iii]. An offender is less likely to commit another crime if they know a DNA database exists. Thus a database like the NDNAD is effective in reducing recidivism.

HUMAN RIGHTS CONCERNS

Since its establishment in 1995, the NDNAD has become indispensable in the criminal justice system of the UK. But the steady expansion of this database has raised several questions regarding privacy and human rights. The UK government had mostly ignored such questions by asserting that the database does not store any sensitive genetic information. It allowed systematic and indefinite retention of DNA profiles of even individuals who were late acquitted. This was challenged before the European Court of Human Rights in S and Marper v UK in 2008. Mr S was a minor who was charged with robbery but later acquitted. Mr Marper was charged with harassment of his partner. But after reconciliation, the case was discontinued. Both S and Marper wanted their DNA samples that were taken during the investigation to be destroyed. But the police refused. The applicants applied for judicial review of the police’s actions but the administrative court rejected their application. The Court of Appeal upheld the administrative court’s decision and the House of Lords dismissed the subsequent appeal. Finally, the case was brought before the European Court of Human Rights. The court found out that there has been a violation of Article 8 of The European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms[iv]. This judgment bought significant changes in the functioning of the NDNAD. Though the NDNAD has posed several threats to the civil liberties of the people, its effectiveness cannot be denied.

THE DNA TECHNOLOGY (USE AND APPLICATION) REGULATION BILL, 2019

India decided to follow the UK’s example by setting up a DNA database. In Interpol’s global DNA profiling survey 2019, it was reported that 70 member countries have a DNA database. India is among the 89 countries that use DNA profiling in police investigation but do not have any database. It seems that India would soon join countries like USA, China and Canada by setting up its databank. The DNA Technology Regulation Bill was introduced in the Lok Sabha in July 2019. The bill later went to the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Science and Technology headed by economist and Congress MP Jairam Ramesh. The committee pointed out in its report how the provisions of the bill can be misused. The fifth chapter of the bill provides for the establishment of a national DNA databank and also a regional DNA databank for every state. The regional bank is required to share all the genetic data stored and maintained by it with the national bank.

ETHICAL CONCERNS

The DNA bill of 2019, much like its predecessors, has been received with widespread criticism. The bill has provoked questions regarding the efficiency of DNA profiling, considering the present state of our criminal justice system, violation of the fundamental right to privacy and lack of proper safeguards for data. There is also a high scope for the misuse of sensitive genetic information for caste-based and minority based profiling. The DNA Regulation bill will allow the government to possess the most private and vulnerable information about an individual. Thus many groups have raised questions regarding the protection of privacy. India, at present, doesn’t have a data protection law. Congress MP Shashi Tharoor, who opposed the bill in Lok Sabha, said that one cannot put the cart before the horse, drawing attention to the lack of proper data protection law. In light of the landmark Puttuswamy judgment, which recognized the right to privacy fundamental right, this bill fails to assure that our genetic information will be properly safeguarded. The provisions of this bill can be manipulated to misuse data. This includes sharing of genetic data with pharmaceutical and insurance agencies[vi].

Another alarming concern raised about this bill is its scope for caste-based and minority profiling. The Parliamentary Standing Committee headed by Jairam Ramesh pointed out how some clauses of the bill can be misused for such profiling. As the data can reveal one’s ethnicity, caste and even skin colour, there is a high probability that a particular caste or community can be linked incorrectly with criminal activities.

The NDNAD has also faced similar criticism. Black men are more likely to be on the database than white men. Dr Alec Jeffery the founding father of DNA profiling found this over-representation of Black and other ethnic minorities in the NDNAD as very discriminatory. Recent studies show that two-thirds of Indian prisons are filled with prisoners from scheduled tribes and Dalits. The statistics are worryingly disproportionate. 13% of the total convicts are from scheduled tribes. But their total share of the Indian population is 8.6 per cent[vii]. This doesn’t necessarily mean that these communities commit more crimes but it shows that they are more vulnerable to exploitation by authorities. This scenario will only get worse with the passing of the bill as it can lead to caste profiling.

CONCLUSION

Despite having several ethical concerns, one cannot deny how useful a national DNA data bank can be. In 2019, over 73,138 children were reported missing, with 71% of them being girls[viii]. A national DNA with a separate missing person’s index can help reunite the missing individuals with their families. It can be extremely useful in nabbing criminals, especially in sexual assault crimes. It is worth reminding that the ilt of the rapists of ‘Nirbhaya’ was established by the Delhi police mainly with DNA evidence. With the help of a huge database, law enforcement agencies can solve crimes more efficiently. But what is the cost? Can the fundamental right to privacy of an individual be infringed upon for the sake of the greater good? In many instances, the rights of a few individuals, especially those from the marginalized sections, are sacrificed on the altar of the ‘collective good’ of the society. Though utilitarianism seems to be the more practical approach, the state should strike a balance by also taking note of the fundamental rights of its citizens. If the concerns over the bill are properly addressed, a DNA database would indeed revolutionize the criminal justice system in our country.

REFERENCES



[i] Robin Mckie, ‘Eureka Moment that led to the discovery of DNA fingerprinting(2009) < https://www.theguardian.com/science/2009/may/24/dna-fingerprinting-alec-jeffreys> accessed 29 January 2022

[ii] ‘What is the UK National DNA Database?’(2014) https://www.yourgenome.org/facts/what-is-the-uk-national-dna-database > accessed 29 January 2022

[iii] Oscar Schwartz, ‘Do DNA databases make would-be criminals think twice?’ (2019) https://thewire.in/the-sciences/dna-database-crime-prevention > accessed 29 January 2022

[iv] Liz Hefernan, ‘DNA and fingerprint data retention: S and Marper v the United Kingdom’, (European Law Review, Vol 34, No 3,June 2005) https://www.researchgate.net/publication/299113198_DNA_and_fingerprint_data_retention_S_and_Marper_v_United_Kingdom > accessed 29 January 2022.

[v] The DNA Technology (Use and Application) Regulation Bill, 2019.

[vi] Payel Upreti, ‘What the DNA profiling bill means for your data privacy’(2019),< https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/blink/know/what-the-dna-profiling-bill-means-for-your-data-privacy/article28793951.ece > accessed 29 January 2022

[vii] Shemin Joy,’ Majority prisoners in Indian jails are Dalits, Muslims’(2020) < https://www.deccanherald.com/national/north-and-central/majority-prisoners-in-indian-jails-are-dalits-muslims-790478.html > accessed 29 January 29, 2022

[viii] Pavitra K.M, ‘Data: the number of missing children increases to 1.2 lakh in 2019’(2020) < https://factly.in/data-number-of-missing-children-cases-increase-to-1-2-lakh-in-2019/> accessed 29 January 2022


DISCLAIMER: This article is an original submission of the Author. Niti Manthan does not hold any liability arising out of this article. Kindly refer to our terms of use or write to us in case of any concerns


Liked the article ?
Share this:

Tags

india ads tv ads ban proposal anti ageing creams government 2006 micro small review big India Juvenile Justice rights Women justice Jurisdiction Constitution caa secularism amendment sedition Arbitration consumer complaint filing international laws wildlife protection animal laws USA china women empowerment pornography legal prostitution sex trafficking laws legalising Economy Measures RBI Coronavirus Reserve Bank of India stability coronavirus impact liquidity shantikanta das monetary policy repo rate moratorium disinformation fake news state of frenzy social media anger hate issue EpidemicDiseaseAct uniformcivilcode equality secular illegalimmigrants immigration assisteddying euthanasia police brutality custodial violence police efforts jail separation divorce hindu marriage family laws economic slowdown unemployment percapitaincome inflation GDP growth aggregate demand commercial surrogacy bill armed forces equal rights landmark judgement indian army transgender living conditions third gender Disability rights rape law Criminal law IPC Internship Program regulatory sandbox IRDA framework IRDA guidelines live environment RBI regulations pollution womeninmates punishment sexualassault wrongfulconvictions IPR EnvironmentLaws JudicialActivism Jurisprudence Internship singleparent adoption niti manthan prison reforms Niti manthan e-fradus cyber crimes It Laws Medico legal aid Media technology and democracy legal literacy Body Offences Housing infrastructure indian law fine global laws right to health fundamental right article 21 Indian penal code criminal law crimes against women rapecases IntellectualPropertyRights Trademark NuclearSecurity Cyberlaws judiciary petitions mercy petition review petition curative petition zero draft human rights business United nations ADR Law mediation negotiation conciliation Mahatama Gandhi economics technology technological unemployment network online consumption production working remotely law of sedition article 19 right to freedom and expression moblynching violence offence animalrights gayparenting pronouns fundamental duties Indian law Constitution of India covid19 criminal justice system constitutional administrative litigation Courts order commission report speedy trial Corrections legal aid legislature Police Successionlaw casestudy SARFAESI e-debate maritalrape 498A IPC Misuse nirbhaya rape case death penalty deterent theory covid-19 force majuere events Force Majeure Clauses coronavirus outbreak doctorine of frustration clauses contract UAPA 2019 Review indigenous people LabourLaws Familylaw dowry death white collar crimes plea bargaining menstruation myths defamation forgery events Results Phase 2 trespass homosexuality mental health intellectual property rights Patent rights crimes lockdown child abuse traditional crime crime rate phishing ransomware cybercrime malware domestic violence doctoring lis pendens applicability conditions insensitive media coverage Muslims media Death murder News channel ayodhya judgement Group Discussion Exceprts naturaljustice legalprincipals Supremecourt crpc Bail Legalethics legal guidelines telemedicine legal issues Laws Section 269 Section 270 cholera privacy concern Divorce Muslim Women retention of property yemen conflict competition law enforcement 10 years administrativelaw PiracyLaw juvenile justice EIA Draft 2020 30th June 2020 Environmental Impact Assessment Climate Change Laws Dissent Research Group juvenile crimes Administration environment conservation Sustainable Oceans Énvironment Appointments Service laws Compassionate Appointments policy legislation webinar scientist climatologist report policy change TPA property patent law section 144 principles of natural justice justice delayed instant justice work from home InformationTechnology persons with disabilities discrimination health girls disease community duties individual contemporary world common interests duality MRTP Act Indian economy competition commission of india Competition Act appraisal singaporean court section 377 Navtej singh judgement IHL war crimes humanitarian law ipc beyond india extra territorial jurisdiction wife maintenance desertion marriage #digital strike #cyber security chinese apps #chinese apps #ad-hoc arbitration #institutional arbitration #environmental law #environment #human rights #strict liability Lok Adalats US-India Abortion laws Live-in-relationships Indian Judiciary Universal Healthcare Rules Based World Order. YL3 victim dying declaration wish last wish truth balanced cooperative bank sarfaesi act Internet Ban Censorship Website Ban #DPSP #state #covid #IP black money racism Skin colour Political system Unrest accountability Jammu and Kashmir Article 370 Abrogation Kidnapping and Abduction Indo-Nepal brutality dk basu guidelines Conflict Changing dynamics democracy international disputes prostitution in India extradition laws and treaties Surrogacy laws case study Law and Order society Legal Implications regulatory framework Betting Gambling Seventh Schedule Central Government Betting Laws Rights of a Man cyber delinquency Juvenile Justice Act Doctrine Part Performance Section 53-A CERC sustainable development Grid Code electricity laws electricity control Mental HealthCare Act WHO National Trust Act Disaster Mangement Indian legal Framework Female Criminality social structure Corporate Laws Corporate Veil Company Election Laws Electoral Reforms Law Commission of India Article 324 Election Commission contempt of court rule of law supreme court principle of natural justice judges criticism high court Fertility Assisted Reproductive Technology Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Bill Legal Evolution Literature growth goods and services Predatory Pricing Market legal remedies cryptocurrency virtual currency santhanam committee ethical behavior border military LAC Aksai Chin revenge porn FIR SC/ ST Reservation artificialintelligence Privacy privacy specialmarriageact constitutional constitutionality Article 139A Education National Education Policy HRDMinistry feminism Gender Inequality Sex god juristic personality PIL Waste Management earth nature ecosystem public trust Section 420 ASCI Advertisements Covid-19 Online Dispute Resolution dispute JusticeOnTime Cyber Space Security election Cloning Senior citizens Human Rights arrest CrPC procedural laws curative legislation Ration card Judicial Review Writ Jurisdiction Internet Covid19 indian passport foreigners-act extradition law laws in India Inheritance Laws Section 6 Domicile CLAT NLU belgium extradition treaty vicarious liability law of torts common law International Commercial Arbitration Private Defence Legal Right energy consumption national solar mission international law economic sanction tax structure Reforms NDPS Act Section64A genocide research projects internships summer school Virtual Courts Digital India NDHM Press Regulation italian-marines fishermen kerala international waters arbitration womenrights witchhunting janaushadischeme healthcare laws medical national health policy healthcare national digital health mission world health organisation legal jurisprudente draft health data management 2020 concerns drawbacks ministry of health and family affair sting operations media trial press rights right to privacy Twitter Prashant Bhushan period leave probate essentials for will will Technical biometrics Laws for women settlement mandalcommission 30 years gandhi principles Indianlegalsystem nitimanthan CELRA Climate Change Phase 3 sakshiaggarwal communication skills youcanskilldevelopment client counselling soumikghoshal sbi protest farm acts agriculture farmers anti-farmers men Executive power constitutional law Article 73 finance transparency political parties bonds Sexual Harassment Ministry of Human Resource Development Educational Reforms DNA evidence sabarimala case untouchability cruelty misuse by women gender biased 488A ban of apps section 69A tiktok app compensation section 357A state s bankruptcy Insolvency_law_committee ibc insolvency_bankruptcy_act insolvency nclt students accessibility retributive theory regulations gender equality internet #righttoeducation nuclear weapon treaty legality advisory opinion international restorative justice punishment theory copyright law distance education virtual teaching Fundamental Rights Rape SC/ST Forest Rights Act Forest Conservation bitcoin child vaccination ibc suspension financial creditors ministry of corporate affairs substantial acquisition takeover public announcement control cci out of court settlement history banking law sebi stressed assets banking regulation dispute resolution professionalism private sector fund sourcing banks publication copyright infringement publishing house penguin environmental jurisprudence 2020 indian legal system acquisition section 62 convertible investees companies act ABUSE ONLINE IPC CRIME WOMEN INDIA ONLINE ABUSE WOMEN CRIME CRIMINAL LAW registrations open competition sushruta apply extempore centre for medical and health law ethic studies medical and health law sex workers prevention religion conversion extra-territorial technological advancement cerestrial environment_protection infrastructure goa doctrineofpleasure crown Arrest code of civil procedure offender access to justice concilation remedy presidentialelections developing nations tiktok universal health coverage comedians freedom of speech and expression OTT Platforms Content Regulation Section 375 forced marriages Precautionary measures Guidelines covid crisis women assault section 353 cops andhra pradesh chief minister dream 11 economic impact online gambling salary income tax rti spam troll misinformation IT Laws data protection information technology act methods civil law section 118 kerala police act section 66a animal rights slaughter customs act CAROTAR FTA TARRIF rules of origin hardship of importer separation of power rights of animals need for amendement meagre punishment legitimacy constitutionalism liability right to healthy environment degrading environment social responsibility restructuring mergers amalgamation traffacking turkey challenge accepted outrage unity child rights rte right to education non-access conclusive proof marital relationships matrimony arbitral award thorium atomic energy act nuclear energy nuclear power atomic energy swadhar home widows vrindavan infringement comparative advertisement trademarks act income tax act non resident indians FEMA MONARCHY SIKKIM namgyal dynasty partner state ONUS guilty Burden of proof legal burden parties self defense legal right Indian constitution prostitutes Winter school International Criminal Law Ministry of Finance Welfare Digital Budget Finance Budget 2021 Democracy Coups Myanmar Voter Fraud Corruption corrupt governments voter fraud unrecognized ineffective Dictators projects development jungle capital assets funds partership water riparian basin collaboration advocate amit mazumdar soft skills advocacy terrorism massacres gun ICC ivorycoast LaurentGbagbo Space Policy Treaties Space Outer space Foreign award public policy ZERO FIR LAW hindu law INDIA PROPERTY RIGHTS DAUGHTER WOMEN RIGHTS AMENDEMENTS HINDU SUCCCESSION distributed ledger technology block chains digital age Exception 2 Habeas Corpus Case Adults Care and Protection Juvenile delinquency Medical Negligence Due Care Criminal Liability Civil Liability Stockholm Conference Uniform Civil Code Personal Laws mental disorder mental health care act advance directive bail sentence CEDAW NCRB Sexual abuse International Bill of Rights POCSO Act Comparative analysis Ted Talk Renewable Energy Trend Energy Projection advaadvance directiv,psychiatry Schedule VII of CA 2013 Amendment 2019 Companies Act 2013 CSR Promoting Innovation and Creativity World Intellectual Property Organisation Restructuring Education Global Innovation Index American Bar Association Offshoring Legal Services Legal Process Outsourcing Marital Rape executive Payment and Settlement System Act of 2007 anti-money laundering Fintech Online Education Inclusion of Technology 5+3+3+4 Design law students call for papers authors editors medical students coparcenory partition safety acts healthworker Policy change Housing Rent Model law Projects Tenancy Central Vista Project Parliament of India supreme court of India space debris Earth orbit Deportation International Law #exploitation exploitation convention equity lawyer movement public interest intoxication alcohol defence involuntary Immoral Traffic Prevention Act Shanbaug Supreme to regarding Euthanasia Difference between life 21 Article and Active Aruna Right Case Passive Court Die Killing Mercy peace challenges policies public crime medical law and ethics Due process of law Procedure established by law misrepresentation enforceability help o&ng mines act petroleum act queer 377 lgbtq anil deshmukh maharashtra shakti act shakti bill daughter personal law devolution testamentary right disturbed areas penalty consumer redressal age evaluations RTI Evidence Act Hearsay Evidence Hearsay Indian Evidence Act Bullying Malice Transferred Malice Transferred Reasonable restrictions unreasonable profits Customer’s consent Unfair trade practices Stoic Evolution of Law Stoicism Temples Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act Endowments Creditor Guarantee Contract Principal Debtor Surety Guarantor Intention Section 304 of IPC Culpable Homicide Knowledge breach of duty legal injury legal duty Negligence inter-country adoption CARA Hague Convention Right of health Sushruta Criminal case Ethics Political Parole State quasi civil social justice Sec 125 torts novus actus interveniens third party beneficiary space law isro nasa criminal trial call out culture kangaroo court extrajudicial accusation corporate social responsibility company law indemnity indemnifier indemnity holder collegium njac surveillance hacking nationalisation Bank Nationalization social control nota voters sports law stem cells research patentibility of stem cells patent Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act secrecyofballot cigarettes health awareness tobacco COTPA pardonpower president doctrineofseparability doctrineofseverability WMD Vietnam Dioxin Operation Ranch Hand Agent Orange Anthrax Family,Women,Hindu,Muslim,Divorce,Marriage Dog tracking evidence,credibility,reliability, international judicial authority chequebounce DishonorofCheque Sec138 NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS ACT,1881 anticompetitiveagreements Article 20(3) right against self-incrimination breach of contract contract law police atrocity victim compensation rehabilitation insider trading share market financial emergency Article 360 specific relief act Private International LAw foreign Judgement Recognition Bio-Medical Waste recycling health care originality ayurveda Ayurvedic treatment public health ancient medicine HIV AIDS NGOs Article 24 #PUDRvs.UOI labor Article 23 conflict between centre and state Indian Federalism concept of federalism youth offenders Tamil Nadu ethics of AI Artifiicial Intelligence karnataka Protection of Right to Freedom of Religion Bill,2021 Language in High Courts Religion Conversion laws Pride Intersex