Is the Indian Federalism in Crisis?: Opinion Paper

May 12, 2022, 6:05 p.m.   n22saha  
Pens of Law students    



AUTHOR'S PROFILE: The author, Bhakti Parekh is enthusiastic about spreading awareness through the written word. She has a love for learning different languages as language gives insight into different thought processes and cultures. She is an avid reader and one of her favourite genres is crime thrillers.


CONCEPT OF FEDERALISM

‘Federalism’ is a term that originates from the Latin word ‘foedus’. It means ‘a treaty or compact’. A form of government where political power is divided by the Sovereign between various units. Thus, “the term ‘federalism’ refers to the constitutionally allocated distribution of powers between two or more levels of government in the nation-state – one, at the national level and the other, at the provincial level, state or local level.”[1] Lord Bryce interestingly describes federalism. “The system was like a great factory wherein two sets of machinery are at work, their revolving wheels intermixed, their bands crossing one another, yet each set doing its work without touching or hampering the other.”[2]

So, it can be seen that in a federal system, both the levels of government have their independence while still being interdependent. Further, the main features of a federal system are that there should exist a written constitution, that such a constitution should be rigid, the judiciary should be independent, both the levels of the government directly affect and operate on the life of citizens, and that there should be an allocation of adequate sources of revenue for the government at each level.[3]

FEDERALISM IN THE INDIAN CONTEXT

Federalism is a vast concept and has the character of being flexible. There exist multiple theories and different kinds of federalism. The type of federalism in the United States is similar yet different from the type of federalism that exists in India. Both the countries have dual polity – one for the Central/Union government and another for the state government. However, that’s where the similarity ends. India, unlike the US, has just one Constitution for the whole country. India, like Canada, adopted the parliamentary-federal system and has a three-tier structure of government that includes the Union and State governments which are based on the constitutional distribution of powers, and the local governments which are based on the devolutionary model established by the state legislature.[4]

It is the ‘Union of India and not the ‘Federation of India’. This is because the federation in India is a result of the devolution of power and not the result of an agreement and no State has the right to secede from it. The words of Dr. Ambedkar help us understand and appreciate this subtle difference. “The federation is a union because it is indestructible. Though the country and the people may be divided into different States for convenience of administration, the country is one integrated whole, its people a single people, living under a single imperium derived from a single source.”[5]

Another interesting fact to note is that the term ‘federal’ has not been used anywhere in the Constitution of India. However, the Union of India has federal attributes which are similar to other federations. The federal structure in India is such that it has a strong Centre.

The Indian federal structure differs from other federations in many ways and has a few special features.

  • There exists a single constitution for both the Union as well as the States.
  • The States do not have separate citizenship and there exists only single citizenship.
  • Common Civil Services – All India Services exist which are common to the Union and the States.
  • A common Comptroller and Auditor-General are appointed by the President of India.
  • A common Election Commission exists
  • There exists a single and integrated judiciary under which the Judges of the Supreme Court and the High Courts are appointed by the President of India.

These features exist to help in avoiding the evils of dual polity and so that unity of the nation is promoted. Ambedkar justified these special features by stating, ‘India will have a federation and at the same time will have uniformity in all the basic matters which are essential to maintain the unity of the country.’[6]

The fact that India is not a federal state in the traditional sense of the term was expressed as an opinion in the case of Pradeep Jain v. Union of India.[7] The Indian Constitution has made the Union or the Centre stronger or more powerful than the states and this asymmetrical or centralized federalism was brought into place to prevent further disunity in the country.[8]

Thus, in the Indian context, it can be said that federalism is asymmetrical and centralized.

PHASES OF INDIAN FEDERALISM

Indian Federalism, since its Independence, has gone through three major phases. In the beginning, there was a single major party in place, i.e., the Congress, and this party consolidated the federal spirit since the beginning. There was a slow process of decentralization that took place while the party was still influential. The creation of states based on linguistic criteria showcased the regional sentiment over that of the centralized nation. The next phase is called the phase of ‘expressive’ federalism. During this phase, the Congress party’s dominance began to weaken and the regional parties began to flourish. It has been called ‘bargaining federalism” by Morris Jones, a British political scientist. It was also called ‘centralized federalism’ by Haqqi and Sharma. There was an active and direct conflict that emerged between the States and the Centre. The third phase is that of ‘multi-party’ federalism. During this phase, there was a significant rise in regional parties and it ushered in a new era of a multi-party system in the Indian political scenario. Coalition politics emerged and it further shaped the federal dynamics in India. Then the fourth phase can be said to be the return of the dominant party or single party in the federal scenario. In this phase, the BJP became the national political force. However, it does face significant opposition from regional parties at the state level.

Thus, it can be seen that the federal dynamics of the country have changed and evolved over some time due to the changing political scenario.

FEDERALISM IN CRISIS?

As discussed before, India is a semi-federal or quasi-federal structure in nature and is so due to the history and diversity of the nation. Whether Indian federalism is in crisis or not can be answered by looking at the issues that are currently being faced in India.

There is a constant power tussle going on between the State governments and the Central government. Though there is a dominant and strong party at the Centre, regional parties command great influence and power in their respective regions. There is a conflict between these regional parties and the party at the Centre. Let’s look at a few issues that have emerged recently in detail.

  • The GST compensation: To persuade States to move to the GST regime, the Union or Centre has promised to cover the shortfall of tax revenues of the states for five years through a GST compensation cess. The purpose of this tax regime was to simplify the complex tax regime in India. By the end of 2019, the GST compensation given to the states was already getting delayed. The Centre citing the massive tax and cess shortfall along with the Covid-19 pandemic stated that it did not have a responsibility to pay states their share. This has led to ill will and a lot of tension between the States and the Centre.
  • The Farm Bills: The Farm Bills that were passed by the Centre have faced vehement opposition from the State governments – especially the States of Punjab and Haryana. It should be noted that the States which are in charge of agriculture were not consulted. Protests against the Bills have been rampant. This whole scenario also shows that there is little to no cooperation between the Union or Centre and the States on important subjects and issues.
  • The next issue is that of the Central Bureau of Investigation. Maharashtra has withdrawn its general consent that had been given to the CBI to investigate and inquire into cases in the state. Because of this, the Central Investigation agency has to take permission or get consent every time it wants to investigate in the state. This showcases the belief that the investigating agencies are not completely apolitical and are considered tools of the Centre used to further political aims.
  • The Current Covid-19 Pandemic: The Covid-19 pandemic which caused the world to halt is another major issue where tensions between the Centre and State governments have risen and the conflicts have become more apparent. The nationwide lockdown that was put into force last year also caused conflict. How the states wanted to manage the scenario and the Centre imposing the nationwide lockdown clarifies that there exists a conflict. The Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman announced that the BJP in its manifesto for the upcoming Bihar elections has made a promise to deliver the Covid-19 vaccine free to all the residents in the state if the party returned to power. It later became clear that the Union government had not engaged in any discussion with the States on the distribution plan for the vaccine and the costs for the same. Focusing on the whole nation at once rather than focusing on the regions and using the federal structure to make the best out of the worst did not happen.

These various issues highlight the conflicts between the State governments and the Union government in various sectors. Co-operation between the Union and the States seems to be something that is very delicate and is in a state of perpetual change. Currently, due to the pandemic, there is an additional tension between the States and the Centre on how to deal with the whole scenario on a national as well as local level.

Based on all this, it can be said that Indian federalism is in crisis because of the constant conflict. Cooperation that is essential for the development of the nation is non-existent and the Centre and States are not on the same page on key issues.

CONCLUSION

From a theoretical perspective, it can be said that the Indian form of federalism is to some extent paradoxical in nature. The parliamentary form of federalism depends heavily on the cooperation of the Union and the States. The point of adopting a semi-federal or quasi-federal structure was so that the states while having a certain amount of autonomy would be able to develop uniformly. That, however, has not happened as there is a lot of disparity in the socio-economic developments of the various States. Conflicts between the States and the Union lead to the issues being dragged out.

The current federal structure and dynamics that exist in India are not ideal to further the goals and objectives of why the federal structure was adopted.



FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

  1. What is the kind of federalism that exists in India?

Ans. India is a quasi-federal or semi-federal. The type of federalism practised in India is called parliamentary federalism.

  1. What did Dr. Ambedkar have to say about the Federal structure of India?

Ans.Dr. Ambedkar thought that the federal structure of India is unique and was made the way it was due to India’s history. He said, “The federation is a union because it is indestructible. Though the country and the people may be divided into different States for convenience of administration, the country is one integrated whole, its people a single people, living under a single imperium derived from a single source.”


Disclaimer: This article is an original submission of the Author. Niti Manthan does not hold any liability arising out of this article. Kindly refer to our terms of use or write to us in case of any concerns.


REFERENCES


[1]George Anderson, Federalism: An Introduction, Oxford, Oxford University Press (2008).

[2]Aaron Wildavsky, American Federalism in Perspective (Little, Brown) (1967).

[3]S.A. Palekar, Federalism: A Conceptual Analysis, 67 The Indian Journal of Political Science (2006).

[4]The Supreme Court of India: The Rise of Judicial Power and the Protection of Federalism, in Courts in Federal Countries, 223–255 (Manish Tewari, Rekha Saxena).

[5]Constituent Assemble Debates, Vol. VII, p. 43.

[6] K.H. Cheluva Raju, Dr. B.R. Ambedkar and Making of the Constitution: A Case Study of Indian Federalism, 52 The Indian Journal of Political Science (1991).

[7]Pradeep Jain v. Union of India, 1984 AIR 1420.

[8]Ambar Kumar Ghosh, The Paradox of ‘Centralised Federalism’: An Analysis of the Challenges to India’s Federal Design, ORF, https://www.orfonline.org/research/the-paradox-of-centralised-federalism/(last visited Apr 6, 2021)



Liked the article ?
Share this:

Tags

india ads tv ads ban proposal anti ageing creams government 2006 micro small review big India Juvenile Justice rights Women justice Jurisdiction Constitution caa secularism amendment sedition Arbitration consumer complaint filing international laws wildlife protection animal laws USA china women empowerment pornography legal prostitution sex trafficking laws legalising Economy Measures RBI Coronavirus Reserve Bank of India stability coronavirus impact liquidity shantikanta das monetary policy repo rate moratorium disinformation fake news state of frenzy social media anger hate issue EpidemicDiseaseAct uniformcivilcode equality secular illegalimmigrants immigration assisteddying euthanasia police brutality custodial violence police efforts jail separation divorce hindu marriage family laws economic slowdown unemployment percapitaincome inflation GDP growth aggregate demand commercial surrogacy bill armed forces equal rights landmark judgement indian army transgender living conditions third gender Disability rights rape law Criminal law IPC Internship Program regulatory sandbox IRDA framework IRDA guidelines live environment RBI regulations pollution womeninmates punishment sexualassault wrongfulconvictions IPR EnvironmentLaws JudicialActivism Jurisprudence Internship singleparent adoption niti manthan prison reforms Niti manthan e-fradus cyber crimes It Laws Medico legal aid Media technology and democracy legal literacy Body Offences Housing infrastructure indian law fine global laws right to health fundamental right article 21 Indian penal code criminal law crimes against women rapecases IntellectualPropertyRights Trademark NuclearSecurity Cyberlaws judiciary petitions mercy petition review petition curative petition zero draft human rights business United nations ADR Law mediation negotiation conciliation Mahatama Gandhi economics technology technological unemployment network online consumption production working remotely law of sedition article 19 right to freedom and expression moblynching violence offence animalrights gayparenting pronouns fundamental duties Indian law Constitution of India covid19 criminal justice system constitutional administrative litigation Courts order commission report speedy trial Corrections legal aid legislature Police Successionlaw casestudy SARFAESI e-debate maritalrape 498A IPC Misuse nirbhaya rape case death penalty deterent theory covid-19 force majuere events Force Majeure Clauses coronavirus outbreak doctorine of frustration clauses contract UAPA 2019 Review indigenous people LabourLaws Familylaw dowry death white collar crimes plea bargaining menstruation myths defamation forgery events Results Phase 2 trespass homosexuality mental health intellectual property rights Patent rights crimes lockdown child abuse traditional crime crime rate phishing ransomware cybercrime malware domestic violence doctoring lis pendens applicability conditions insensitive media coverage Muslims media Death murder News channel ayodhya judgement Group Discussion Exceprts naturaljustice legalprincipals Supremecourt crpc Bail Legalethics legal guidelines telemedicine legal issues Laws Section 269 Section 270 cholera privacy concern Divorce Muslim Women retention of property yemen conflict competition law enforcement 10 years administrativelaw PiracyLaw juvenile justice EIA Draft 2020 30th June 2020 Environmental Impact Assessment Climate Change Laws Dissent Research Group juvenile crimes Administration environment conservation Sustainable Oceans Énvironment Appointments Service laws Compassionate Appointments policy legislation webinar scientist climatologist report policy change TPA property patent law section 144 principles of natural justice justice delayed instant justice work from home InformationTechnology persons with disabilities discrimination health girls disease community duties individual contemporary world common interests duality MRTP Act Indian economy competition commission of india Competition Act appraisal singaporean court section 377 Navtej singh judgement IHL war crimes humanitarian law ipc beyond india extra territorial jurisdiction wife maintenance desertion marriage #digital strike #cyber security chinese apps #chinese apps #ad-hoc arbitration #institutional arbitration #environmental law #environment #human rights #strict liability Lok Adalats US-India Abortion laws Live-in-relationships Indian Judiciary Universal Healthcare Rules Based World Order. YL3 victim dying declaration wish last wish truth balanced cooperative bank sarfaesi act Internet Ban Censorship Website Ban #DPSP #state #covid #IP black money racism Skin colour Political system Unrest accountability Jammu and Kashmir Article 370 Abrogation Kidnapping and Abduction Indo-Nepal brutality dk basu guidelines Conflict Changing dynamics democracy international disputes prostitution in India extradition laws and treaties Surrogacy laws case study Law and Order society Legal Implications regulatory framework Betting Gambling Seventh Schedule Central Government Betting Laws Rights of a Man cyber delinquency Juvenile Justice Act Doctrine Part Performance Section 53-A CERC sustainable development Grid Code electricity laws electricity control Mental HealthCare Act WHO National Trust Act Disaster Mangement Indian legal Framework Female Criminality social structure Corporate Laws Corporate Veil Company Election Laws Electoral Reforms Law Commission of India Article 324 Election Commission contempt of court rule of law supreme court principle of natural justice judges criticism high court Fertility Assisted Reproductive Technology Assisted Reproductive Technology (Regulation) Bill Legal Evolution Literature growth goods and services Predatory Pricing Market legal remedies cryptocurrency virtual currency santhanam committee ethical behavior border military LAC Aksai Chin revenge porn FIR SC/ ST Reservation artificialintelligence Privacy privacy specialmarriageact constitutional constitutionality Article 139A Education National Education Policy HRDMinistry feminism Gender Inequality Sex god juristic personality PIL Waste Management earth nature ecosystem public trust Section 420 ASCI Advertisements Covid-19 Online Dispute Resolution dispute JusticeOnTime Cyber Space Security election Cloning Senior citizens Human Rights arrest CrPC procedural laws curative legislation Ration card Judicial Review Writ Jurisdiction Internet Covid19 indian passport foreigners-act extradition law laws in India Inheritance Laws Section 6 Domicile CLAT NLU belgium extradition treaty vicarious liability law of torts common law International Commercial Arbitration Private Defence Legal Right energy consumption national solar mission international law economic sanction tax structure Reforms NDPS Act Section64A genocide research projects internships summer school Virtual Courts Digital India NDHM Press Regulation italian-marines fishermen kerala international waters arbitration womenrights witchhunting janaushadischeme healthcare laws medical national health policy healthcare national digital health mission world health organisation legal jurisprudente draft health data management 2020 concerns drawbacks ministry of health and family affair sting operations media trial press rights right to privacy Twitter Prashant Bhushan period leave probate essentials for will will Technical biometrics Laws for women settlement mandalcommission 30 years gandhi principles Indianlegalsystem nitimanthan CELRA Climate Change Phase 3 sakshiaggarwal communication skills youcanskilldevelopment client counselling soumikghoshal sbi protest farm acts agriculture farmers anti-farmers men Executive power constitutional law Article 73 finance transparency political parties bonds Sexual Harassment Ministry of Human Resource Development Educational Reforms DNA evidence sabarimala case untouchability cruelty misuse by women gender biased 488A ban of apps section 69A tiktok app compensation section 357A state s bankruptcy Insolvency_law_committee ibc insolvency_bankruptcy_act insolvency nclt students accessibility retributive theory regulations gender equality internet #righttoeducation nuclear weapon treaty legality advisory opinion international restorative justice punishment theory copyright law distance education virtual teaching Fundamental Rights Rape SC/ST Forest Rights Act Forest Conservation bitcoin child vaccination ibc suspension financial creditors ministry of corporate affairs substantial acquisition takeover public announcement control cci out of court settlement history banking law sebi stressed assets banking regulation dispute resolution professionalism private sector fund sourcing banks publication copyright infringement publishing house penguin environmental jurisprudence 2020 indian legal system acquisition section 62 convertible investees companies act ABUSE ONLINE IPC CRIME WOMEN INDIA ONLINE ABUSE WOMEN CRIME CRIMINAL LAW registrations open competition sushruta apply extempore centre for medical and health law ethic studies medical and health law sex workers prevention religion conversion extra-territorial technological advancement cerestrial environment_protection infrastructure goa doctrineofpleasure crown Arrest code of civil procedure offender access to justice concilation remedy presidentialelections developing nations tiktok universal health coverage comedians freedom of speech and expression OTT Platforms Content Regulation Section 375 forced marriages Precautionary measures Guidelines covid crisis women assault section 353 cops andhra pradesh chief minister dream 11 economic impact online gambling salary income tax rti spam troll misinformation IT Laws data protection information technology act methods civil law section 118 kerala police act section 66a animal rights slaughter customs act CAROTAR FTA TARRIF rules of origin hardship of importer separation of power rights of animals need for amendement meagre punishment legitimacy constitutionalism liability right to healthy environment degrading environment social responsibility restructuring mergers amalgamation traffacking turkey challenge accepted outrage unity child rights rte right to education non-access conclusive proof marital relationships matrimony arbitral award thorium atomic energy act nuclear energy nuclear power atomic energy swadhar home widows vrindavan infringement comparative advertisement trademarks act income tax act non resident indians FEMA MONARCHY SIKKIM namgyal dynasty partner state ONUS guilty Burden of proof legal burden parties self defense legal right Indian constitution prostitutes Winter school International Criminal Law Ministry of Finance Welfare Digital Budget Finance Budget 2021 Democracy Coups Myanmar Voter Fraud Corruption corrupt governments voter fraud unrecognized ineffective Dictators projects development jungle capital assets funds partership water riparian basin collaboration advocate amit mazumdar soft skills advocacy terrorism massacres gun ICC ivorycoast LaurentGbagbo Space Policy Treaties Space Outer space Foreign award public policy ZERO FIR LAW hindu law INDIA PROPERTY RIGHTS DAUGHTER WOMEN RIGHTS AMENDEMENTS HINDU SUCCCESSION distributed ledger technology block chains digital age Exception 2 Habeas Corpus Case Adults Care and Protection Juvenile delinquency Medical Negligence Due Care Criminal Liability Civil Liability Stockholm Conference Uniform Civil Code Personal Laws mental disorder mental health care act advance directive bail sentence CEDAW NCRB Sexual abuse International Bill of Rights POCSO Act Comparative analysis Ted Talk Renewable Energy Trend Energy Projection advaadvance directiv,psychiatry Schedule VII of CA 2013 Amendment 2019 Companies Act 2013 CSR Promoting Innovation and Creativity World Intellectual Property Organisation Restructuring Education Global Innovation Index American Bar Association Offshoring Legal Services Legal Process Outsourcing Marital Rape executive Payment and Settlement System Act of 2007 anti-money laundering Fintech Online Education Inclusion of Technology 5+3+3+4 Design law students call for papers authors editors medical students coparcenory partition safety acts healthworker Policy change Housing Rent Model law Projects Tenancy Central Vista Project Parliament of India supreme court of India space debris Earth orbit Deportation International Law #exploitation exploitation convention equity lawyer movement public interest intoxication alcohol defence involuntary Immoral Traffic Prevention Act Shanbaug Supreme to regarding Euthanasia Difference between life 21 Article and Active Aruna Right Case Passive Court Die Killing Mercy peace challenges policies public crime medical law and ethics Due process of law Procedure established by law misrepresentation enforceability help o&ng mines act petroleum act queer 377 lgbtq anil deshmukh maharashtra shakti act shakti bill daughter personal law devolution testamentary right disturbed areas penalty consumer redressal age evaluations RTI Evidence Act Hearsay Evidence Hearsay Indian Evidence Act Bullying Malice Transferred Malice Transferred Reasonable restrictions unreasonable profits Customer’s consent Unfair trade practices Stoic Evolution of Law Stoicism Temples Hindu Religious and Charitable Endowments Act Endowments Creditor Guarantee Contract Principal Debtor Surety Guarantor Intention Section 304 of IPC Culpable Homicide Knowledge breach of duty legal injury legal duty Negligence inter-country adoption CARA Hague Convention Right of health Sushruta Criminal case Ethics Political Parole State quasi civil social justice Sec 125 torts novus actus interveniens third party beneficiary space law isro nasa criminal trial call out culture kangaroo court extrajudicial accusation corporate social responsibility company law indemnity indemnifier indemnity holder collegium njac surveillance hacking nationalisation Bank Nationalization social control nota voters sports law stem cells research patentibility of stem cells patent Arbitration and Conciliation (Amendment) Act secrecyofballot cigarettes health awareness tobacco COTPA pardonpower president doctrineofseparability doctrineofseverability WMD Vietnam Dioxin Operation Ranch Hand Agent Orange Anthrax Family,Women,Hindu,Muslim,Divorce,Marriage Dog tracking evidence,credibility,reliability, international judicial authority chequebounce DishonorofCheque Sec138 NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS ACT,1881 anticompetitiveagreements Article 20(3) right against self-incrimination breach of contract contract law police atrocity victim compensation rehabilitation insider trading share market financial emergency Article 360 specific relief act Private International LAw foreign Judgement Recognition Bio-Medical Waste recycling health care originality ayurveda Ayurvedic treatment public health ancient medicine HIV AIDS NGOs Article 24 #PUDRvs.UOI labor Article 23 conflict between centre and state Indian Federalism concept of federalism youth offenders Tamil Nadu ethics of AI Artifiicial Intelligence karnataka Protection of Right to Freedom of Religion Bill,2021 Language in High Courts Religion Conversion laws Pride Intersex